rungfolio

The buy-and-hold comparison

perf.buy-and-hold

What it measures

What the same money would have done if it had been invested in the ticker on the first day and held to the end.

How it's worked out

  • On the first session, the starting cash buys as many whole shares as it can at that day's opening price. Whatever is left over stays as cash.
  • In the Journal's charts, the money is what the account had going into its first night on the chart: the cash it last started over with, or, when the dates you chose start later, its value at the close of its last night before them. If the ticker's daily prices start after that first night, the comparison buys on the first night it can, with the account's value at the close of the night before.
  • With several accounts, each holds its own money from its own first night, and the comparison adds them up night by night, as the account values are. Both returns then count from all the money the accounts put in, so an account that joins partway doesn't count as a gain. If one account's comparison can't start on its own first night, the two lines don't start from the same money, so the chart gives their values and no returns.
  • Nothing is bought or sold after that. A split changes the shares as your broker would: they're multiplied by the ratio and rounded down, and a fraction of a share left over is paid out in cash at the ex-date's opening price, as a split pays a lot's.
  • At each close, the comparison is worth its shares at that close plus its cash. Its total return and its maximum drawdown are worked out from those values, the same way as the ladder's. Both drawdowns start from the starting cash, on the night before the first session, so a fall on the first day counts.
  • Neither side is paid dividends, and cash earns no interest on either side. So on a fund that pays dividends, holding it would have returned about its yield more each year than the comparison shows.

Example

$10,000 at an opening price of $99.50 buys 100 whole shares, which cost $9,950, and leaves $50 as cash. At a close of $98.40, the comparison is worth 100 × $98.40 + $50 = $9,890: a return of −1.1%.

Where you'll see it

Every backtest shows buy-and-hold beside its result, whether or not the ladder came out ahead: its value night by night on the chart, and its return and maximum drawdown beside the ladder's. A backtest tests a ladder's settings on past prices. The public showcase on rungfolio.com will show it the same way, for every ticker it covers, even when a result is poor.

Compare, which puts two to four saved runs side by side, draws each run's buy-and-hold dashed beside the run, in the same color, both as returns from the run's starting cash (reading a backtest).

The Journal's Charts view draws it beside your practice account's value, night by night. It holds the ticker of the account's first ladder unless you choose another, such as SPY, to compare with the market as a whole. A ticker whose daily prices start after your first night, or end before your last, holds only while it has prices, and the chart says so.

The comparison answers one question: did the ladder do better or worse than simply holding? To read the ladder's own result next to it, see return on capital used and maximum drawdown.

Educational software, not investment advice.